Don't know why still the site is acting in a manner that many mails have to be resend.
A communication from Dr Kailash Bihari ji is appended below.
Regards,
Amit Anand
Sent on my BlackBerry? from Vodafone
-----Original Message-----
From: bihari2003 at aol.co.uk
Date: Wed, 05 May 2010 02:57:28
To: <anand.aadyaa at gmail.com>
Subject: Fwd: [noba-all] NOBA help fund and Ravi's assistance
-----Original Message-----
From: bihari2003 at aol.co.uk
To: prof.prabhat.ranjan at gmail.com
Cc: noba-all at noba.org
Sent: Wed, May 5, 2010 11:30 am
Subject: Re: [noba-all] NOBA help fund and Ravi's assistance
Dear prabhat,
If I were you, I would have thought thousands of time before posting this to noba-all.
Ravi's expectations are well founded and rightly placed. He is one of us. This sense of belonging evaporated at the door step of ortho surgeon of Gaya where expression of being a nobite drew nil response. This sad in every term of fraternity and noble image of my profession. Ravi was there to beg help as a younger brother. Whose setup did he meet at doctor's door that vanished his confidence in all of us?. He must have felt there being treated as a slum dog.
His decision to walk away from that spot was correct as it shielded his soul from further injury. Don't forget the fact that in front of him was an injured father agonizing in severe pain.
Doctors are not Gods and they must not mimic as such. Walt Whitman still is a revered figure because he dictated a lesson to all of us to be taken to heart;"DOOR OF A DOCTOR AND THAT OF CLERGY MUST NEVER CLOSE".
Not only I remember this, I have lived as such from day one of my professional engagement. Even after retirement and clear declaration of no more clinics only thing I did is removal of my name plate as practicing physician. Door has never closed. Anyone who ring my door bell any time gets answered by myself. Only yesterday some drove 65 km because he heard that bihari doctor was expected to return from England at the end of April.
He had come with hope. I honored his hope. I don't charge fee for consultation. Inspite of my protest he left Rs 400= on my table saying it will make him happy if I accepted it. My +ve nod saw a big smile on his face. I have set aside that money for Ravi.
If your younger is buckling under a debt but dares not to reveal to you , is there anything wrong in recognizing his need and agony through someone who has won his confidence enough that allowed Ravi give full authority to highlight his plight. Amit Anand is doing a humane act and by pointing any finger to him or using his name for a target practice to satisfy sickening desire of ego message, is not becoming of a Nobite. Be it a Bose or Das or anyone from timbucktoo, I wish to pass this massage-IF YOU CANT TAKE THE PLEASE DO NOT ENTER THE KITCHEN ANDstop showing your certificate that you have done a cookery course. Family of nobite has enough highly trained and skilled hands that can make life palatable out of any crisis.
I am doing all that one should. Even Shriman Kantiji came forward for assistance and guidance.
After studying some of mail I was filled so much despair that questioned him about reasons behind selecting so many dim bits to be crowned with Hatian glory.
As I expressed on noba.org, I am booking my journey to Gaya to take stock of the situation.And to all of you I wish to make clear that Amit Anand is not a Mumbaikar but a Gurgonkar. He is acting on behalf Gurgaon Nobite team under the direct gaze of seniors. Today We shall meet to decide "what next?".
Please let it go through to noba-all
All response to me please.
Dr Kailash Bihari 1958 batch.
-----Original Message-----
From: Prabhat Ranjan <prof.prabhat.ranjan at gmail.com>
To: noba-all at noba.org
Sent: Wed, May 5, 2010 8:50 am
Subject: [noba-all] NOBA help fund and Ravi's assistance
This is copy of a post to noba.org forum - respond at the link :
http://noba.org/index.php?option=com_kunena&Itemid=65&func=view&catid=8&id=54#54
=====================================================
>From time to time certain emergency situation has been brought to
notice of NOBA community for assistance. Almost in all cases, NOBA
community has responded as per the need of situation. It is also at
such time that need for a common fund to respond to the immediate
needs has been raised. I have following points in this:
1. I think Netarhat has given us good lessons to develop our
capabilities and progress in our career to support ourselves both
financially and emotionally.
2. Most of us go through stages in our life to where we are
down(financially/emotionally/...). Family and community (e.g NOBA)
does provide some level of support in such situation but in most cases
we learn to get up on out feet again and move ahead in our life.
3. For financial needs arising out of unforeseen circumstances (in the
past, we have had accidents or life crippling diseases of NOBA
members), we have suggested creating some kind of group insurance
scheme to cater to such needs based on contribution from beneficiary
of such schemes.
4. In the recent case of help to Ravi, certain things come to my mind
with which I am not comfortable (However I have no doubts about Amit
Anand's good intentions):
* for three years there seems to be medical expenses of Ravi's son and
father. Suggestion is being made to cover expenses for such period and
to provide enough funds to cover various medical and related needs
(e.g fruit and milk)
* In last three years, with so many good NOBA doctors around
(including Dr Shree Prakash Jee in Gaya), no one was contacted.
* A reason was given that Compounder misbehaved when Ravi wanted to go
out of queue and meet Dr ShreePrakash Jee. I always go and stand in
line for Doctors advice or seek a prior appointment(even if Doctor
happens to be my friend).
* Ravi says that he has borrowed from market to pay for his father's
expenses. He expects NOBA community to cover his expenses made to
clear his debts. I am not sure if such an expectation is justified,
when in three years he did not meet even one NOBA doctor.
I have no issues with NOBA community finding Ravi a better paying job
assuming that employer is satisfied with the qualification and
capability. I would request that discussion on this issue be carried
out on forum and not on noba-all mailing list. I am copying this post
to noba-all so that they are aware of this posting. You can subscribe
in the forum to this topic so that you get mails related to any
postings on this.
Thanks,
- Prabhat Ranjan
(1970147, Nalanda)
_______________________________________________
noba-all mailing list
noba-all at noba.org
http://box405.bluehost.com/mailman/listinfo/noba-all_noba.org
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <
http://box405.bluehost.com/mailman/private/noba-all_noba.org/attachments/20100505/bc321459/attachment.htm>
Received on Wed May 05 2010 - 01:17:44 IST